14

Products Tested

research icon

25

Hours of Research

reviews icon

55

Reviews Examined

Nothing beats the bold, smooth, and slightly fruity taste of Colombian coffee, but when I switched to Keurig coffee, I found that some Colombian K-cups just did not hit the spot.

I decided to create the definitive list of the best Colombian coffee K cups to help make life easier for other home brewers who love Colombian coffee.

I researched, tried, tested, and tasted over 20 different Colombian coffee brands to find the best Colombian coffee K cups.

In this guide, I’ll introduce the best 7 options that any true Colombian coffee lover must try.

OUR TOP PICK

Folgers
100% Colombian Coffee
K-Cup

Taste

5.0

Size Options

4.5

Value For Money

5.0


Our Score

4.8

CHEAPEST OPTION

Green Mountain
Coffee Roasters Colombia Select K-Cup

Taste

4.5

Size Options

4.5

Value For Money

5.0


Our Score

4.7

Most Popular

McCafe
Colombian Roast
K-Cup

Taste

4.5

Size Options

4.5

Value For Money

5.0


Our Score

4.7

1. Folgers 100% Colombian Coffee K-Cup

Taste

5.0

Size Options

4.5

Value For Money

5.0


Overall Rating

4.8

Price Per Count

$0.75

Roast Level

Medium

Taste

Bold, bright, lively, with chocolatey notes and a citrus finish

Bean Type

Single-origin Arabica beans

Caffeine Per Cup

120mg

What I love about Folgers medium roast Colombian coffee is the rich and smooth coffee taste. It's effortless to drink but not weak, giving you Colombian flavors in every sip.

I also love the strong caffeine boost it provides.

Folgers medium roast Colombian coffee is smooth, bold, and satisfying. It has rich and lively flavors and is one of the best Colombian coffee brands for all coffee drinkers.

The only slight downside is the price because it is more expensive than other brands. However, it’s higher quality than the McCafe or Green Mountain budget pods and is still good value for money.

Folgers Colombian K-cup coffee is perfect for those who want interesting coffee every day.

It may not have the complexity of the Eight O'Clock Coffee K cups, but it's a versatile K cup that newbie and veteran coffee drinkers will enjoy.

Pros

  • Deeply satisfying brew of bold and interesting flavors
  • Works well with milk and sugar
  • More caffeine
  • Amazing aroma

Cons

  • More expensive than other brands

2. Green Mountain Coffee Roasters Colombia Select K-Cup

Taste

4.5

Size Options

4.5

Value For Money

5.0


Overall Rating

4.7

Price Per Count

$0.55

Roast Level

Medium

Taste

Notes of caramel and chocolate with a soft, sweet, and fruity finish

Bean Type

Single-origin Arabica beans

Caffeine Per Cup

115mg

The Green Mountain Colombia has a smooth flavor and is incredibly balanced. It’s high-quality but perfect for relaxed coffee drinking.

Green Mountain may not have the lively flavor of Folgers K cups, but it’s still distinctive.

There’s a sweet, rich flavor with caramel and brown sugar notes, rounded out by apricot and apple notes. There’s also no bitter aftertaste, which is great for more casual coffee drinkers.

What I love about Green Mountain single-serve coffee K cups is the quality, and I don’t just mean in the Columbian coffee.

Unlike other brands, the packaging and pods are always in excellent condition and never cause any issues.

Despite the quality, Green Mountain is competitively priced and cheaper than Folgers or Maud’s Columbian coffee K cups.

These are the best K cups for less refined pallets looking to explore the rich flavor of Colombian coffee. It’s flavorsome and drinkable and perfect for drinking throughout the day.

Pros

  • Consistent taste in every pod
  • Smooth, with no bitter taste
  • Great for casual coffee-drinking
  • Half-caff and low-caffeine options available

Cons

  • Not as bold as other blends

3. McCafe Colombian Roast K-Cup

Taste

4.5

Size Options

4.5

Value For Money

5.0


Overall Rating

4.7

Price Per Count

$0.50

Roast Level

Medium-dark

Taste

Crisp, fresh, and clean with chocolate notes, a medium body, and fruity aftertaste

Bean Type

Blend of Arabica beans

Caffeine Per Cup

90mg

You might not associate McDonald's with great coffee, but these are some of the best Colombian coffee pods available.

They capture the taste of the region and are perfect for those who enjoy crisp, clean, and mildly fruity coffee.

This K-cup is made with medium dark roast coffee. This gives bolder and earthier flavors than the Green Mountain Colombian medium roast.

While it does lack the complexity of the Eight O'Clock Coffee K cups, the strong coffee flavor makes it perfect for milky coffee drinks (like lattes and cappuccinos).

That said, experienced coffee drinkers may find it to be too basic.

The McCafe Colombian K cup is also one of the most affordable, so you can get all the flavors of Colombia without spending a fortune.

The McCafe K cup captures the flavors of Colombia well. It's not as delicately flavored as other brands, but it's perfect for coffee drinkers who usually add milk, cream, or other additions.

Pros

  • Bolder taste from the medium-dark roast
  • Great in milky coffees
  • Affordable
  • Kosher Certified
  • Rainforest Alliance certified

Cons

  • Has a more generic coffee taste
  • Lower caffeine level

4. Eight O'Clock Coffee Colombian Peaks K-Cup

Taste

4.0

Size Options

4.5

Value For Money

5.0


Overall Rating

4.5

Price Per Count

$0.60

Roast Level

Medium

Taste

Full-bodied, with a complex flavor profile. Has nutty and chocolate notes and a sweet finish

Bean Type

Single-origin Arabica coffee

Caffeine Per Cup

110mg

Eight O'Clock medium roast coffee has more complex flavors than Green Mountain or McCafe K-cups because the beans are grown at a high altitude.

This gives them a full body and brings out the sweeter notes found only in Colombia.

If you enjoy complex coffee, you’ll love this Colombian medium roast K cup. It’s nutty and chocolatey, with a fruity finish, balancing light and dark notes in one cup.

What’s even better about Eight O’Clock coffee is the consistency. Every single serve Keurig pod tastes identical, so you know you’re getting the same taste every time.

They are also reasonably priced (though not as cheap as the McCafe or Green Mountain Keurig pods).

This is an everyday coffee, but it is best for those who like brewing interesting coffees rather than standard brews.

Pros

  • Rich with no bitter notes
  • Reliable and consistent in every box
  • Certified Kosher
  • Fair Trade

Cons

  • Less pronounced aroma

5. Gevalia Colombia K-Cup

Taste

4.5

Size Options

4.0

Value For Money

4.0


Overall Rating

4.2

Price Per Count

$0.70

Roast Level

Medium

Taste

Rich and bright with notes of caramel and citrus

Bean Type

Single-origin Arabica beans

Caffeine Per Cup

100mg

The Gevalia Colombia K-cup is one of the freshest I've tasted.

The mix of sweet caramel notes, citrus taste, and floral aroma gives it a bright and zesty edge that contrasts the deeper McCafe and Green Mountain blends.

The bright notes are a result of the growing process. Gevalia grows coffee beans on the elevated mountain areas where the beans thrive.

Their experienced coffee farmers know how to maximize and preserve the flavor, and this coffee is grown to perfection so you can enjoy it at home.

The only downside with Gevalia Colombian medium roast is that it costs slightly more, but it still offers some good value.

Gevalia has a long history of making premium coffee, and it shows here. This is the perfect morning coffee and best for those who appreciate smooth coffee with subtle flavors.

Pros

  • Bright and fresh flavor profile
  • Amazing coffee beans from experienced farmers
  • High-quality box and Keurig K cups
  • Silky smooth
  • Consistent flavor in every pod

Cons

  • Doesn’t have that coffee punch some people enjoy
  • Doesn’t blend as well with milk or cream

6. Victor Allen's Coffee 100% Colombian

Taste

4.0

Size Options

4.0

Value For Money

4.0


Overall Rating

4.0

Price Per Count

$0.40

Roast Level

Medium

Taste

Mild, well-balanced, and medium-bodied. Hints of cocoa and nuts with a very smooth finish.

Bean Type

Blend of Arabica coffee beans

Caffeine Per Cup

120mg

Victor Allen is another well-known coffee brand with a good reputation, and this is one of the best medium roast Colombian coffee K cups I've tasted.

It's smooth, well-balanced, and mild - great for less experienced coffee drinkers.

The smooth and mild flavor comes from the mix of Arabica beans. The blend of roasted beans gives you chocolatey and malty notes, but they're fairly subtler than other coffees.

There's no bold kick like the McCafe K-cups, just mellow coffee flavors.

The taste makes Victor Allen's Colombian coffee a great everyday brew, and the cost backs that up.

These are the cheapest K-cups on the list and great for anyone who wants Colombian coffee on a budget.

The beans and process make this classic coffee mild and easy to drink. If you want a casual coffee with bags of flavor, you'll love these Colombian medium roast K-cups.

Pros

  • Mild, mellow, and well-balanced
  • Mixes well with milk, cream, and sugar
  • GMO-free
  • Very affordable - great for any budget

Cons

  • Less pronounced Colombian flavor

7. Maud's Organic Colombian Coffee

Taste

4.0

Size Options

3.5

Value For Money

4.0


Overall Rating

3.8

Price Per Count

$0.80

Roast Level

Medium

Taste

Sweet, medium-bodied, with intense caramel notes and nutty undertones

Bean Type

Single-origin Arabica beans

Caffeine Per Cup

120mg

Maud’s Colombian coffee is a slightly darker roast than Green Mountain or Folgers, giving it more complexity. 

The sweet notes and smooth body in Maud's medium roast Colombian coffee come from organic beans.

It has deep, nutty flavors mixed with caramel sweetness. The taste, texture, and rich aroma make it an unpretentious and delicious brew.

They're grown in the elevated region of Colombia and then roasted to perfection in small batches. This helps to enhance the flavor more than other Colombian medium roast Keurig K-cups.

Maud's is also a responsible company, using solar energy to power their operation entirely.

Plus, they're Fair Trade and fully recyclable, so when you're brewing, you know you're supporting an ethical company.

Maud’s organic Colombian K cups are more expensive than other brands but are simple, sweet, and smooth.

They work well on their own or blended with additions and are best for casual coffee drinkers.

Pros

  • Organic and Fair Trade
  • Solar powered operation
  • Sweet and smooth taste
  • High quality - similar to what you would get in coffee shops
  • Big energy boost

Cons

  • Not the best quality K-cup pods
  • Slightly more expensive brand

How To Choose a Quality Colombian Coffee K-Cups

The list above contains some of the best Colombian coffee K cups, but you can always search for your own.

Here are the key factors to consider when you’re looking at different Colombian coffee brands:

Price Per Count Matters!

K cups typically cost $0.40-$0.60 per pod, but it varies depending on the brand and volume you order.

If (like me) you love coffee, that can mean you’re spending upwards of $750 on K cups each year.

Unfortunately, Colombian K cups are usually more expensive and typically cost $0.60-$0.80 per pod. This higher price is because it's higher quality coffee, and more effort goes into growing it.

While you should expect to pay more for the best Colombian coffee brands, that doesn’t mean there are no options for those on a limited budget.

Victor Allen is the best Colombian coffee K cup for those on a budget. These K cups are made with high-quality Colombian beans and give you a flavorful coffee without the hefty price tag.

Cheapest: Victor Allen's 100% Colombian

Most Expensive: Maud's Organic Colombian Coffee

Tasting Notes and Flavor Profile Will Vary!

Colombian coffee typically has smooth, chocolate flavors with bright citrus and fruity notes.

However, part of the reason Colombian coffee is so popular is because there are a wide range of flavors to choose from.

This is because there are 4 different growing regions, and the environmental conditions in each change the flavor profile of the coffee.[1]

Maud's Organic Colombian Coffee Lifestyle

That’s why Colombian coffee brands can all taste very different.

It’s worth exploring the Colombian coffee flavors before you choose your Colombian coffee K cups because there is something for everyone.

  • If you enjoy a deep, earthy brew with a traditional coffee flavor, I recommend McCafe Colombian coffee K cups.
  • If you prefer smooth, mellow, everyday coffees, I recommend the Folgers or Maud’s Colombian coffee K cups.
  • If you prefer something more complex and unique, Eight O'Clock Coffee pods are the best Colombian coffee K-cups for you.

Remember, it's not one size fits all, so you should sample a few of the best Colombian coffee brands to find your favorite flavors.

Learn About Roast Level

The roast level of your coffee beans has a noticeable impact on the flavor of your brew.[2]

Take some time to learn about roast levels and choose the best Colombian coffee roast to suit your taste buds.

Colombian coffee is usually best as a light or medium roast because it retains more unique Colombian flavors. However, you can get some delicious dark-roasted Colombian coffees.

Here's a quick summary of the three roast levels and what to expect from each:

Dark Roast Coffee

This has been roasted for the longest time (usually 15-25 minutes).

This prolonged exposure to high temperatures gives coffee deep, toasty flavors and usually brings out notes of chocolate. Dark roast is full-bodied but can be slightly bitter.

Best Dark Roast: McCafe Colombian K-Cups

Medium Roast Coffee

Medium roast coffee is roasted for longer than light roasts but shorter than dark roasts (usually 8-12 minutes).

Medium roast is the most balanced coffee, with a medium body and smooth taste. It’s also the most versatile and the best roast for beginners.

Best Medium Roast: Folgers 100% Colombian

Folgers 100% Colombian Coffee K-Cup Lifestyle
Light Roast Coffee

Light roast coffee is roasted for the shortest time (usually under 10 minutes).

This preserves more of the natural flavors of the coffee bean, so light roast flavors will vary depending on the coffee bean used.

Typically, they have delicate, complex flavors with citrus or floral notes.

If you enjoy interesting coffees and have a more sophisticated pallet, I recommend you purchase a light roast K-cup.

Know The Caffeine Content

Most of us drink coffee for the caffeine boost, so it's an important consideration when choosing your K-cups.

The average single-serve coffee K-cup pod has 75-150mg of caffeine. Colombian coffee only uses Arabica beans, which contain less caffeine than Robusta beans.[3]

This means that Colombian coffee K-cups contain usually 100-150mg.

However, you can choose K cups with higher or lower levels of caffeine to suit your preferences.

If you want a larger energy boost, I recommend the Folgers or Victor Allen Colombian coffee K cups because they contain the most caffeine.

If you want to cut back on caffeine, I recommend checking out the Folgers decaf K-cups. These have all the flavor but under 10mg of caffeine.

Most Caffeine: Folgers Colombian K-Cups (120mg)

Least Caffeine: McCafe Colombian Roast (90mg)

Is It Compatible With Your Machine?

Before you choose any Colombian coffee K-cup, ensure it works in your machine.

Keurig K cup brewers are only compatible with Keurig K-cups, and other coffee pods will not work in them. Make sure you buy Colombian K-cups and not generic coffee pods.

All 7 of the best Colombian K cups listed above will work in Keurig machines (including Keurig 2.0 brewers).

If browsing other Colombian coffee brands, check the specifications to ensure they are compatible.

Inserting A McCafe Colombian Roast K-Cup Into Keurig

Common Colombian Coffee Pod Questions

Why is Colombian coffee so famous?

Colombian coffee is famous because it's regarded as some of the best in the world, with a taste and aroma considered superior by most in the coffee industry. This is down to the rich Colombian coffee industry history and the perfect environmental conditions for growing great coffee beans.

Is Colombian coffee high in caffeine?

Colombian coffee typically has slightly less caffeine than other coffee types because it's made entirely from Arabica coffee beans that contain less caffeine than Robusta beans.

Is Colombian coffee acidic?

Yes, Colombian coffee is known for its high acidity, and it's one of the factors that makes it such a flavorful coffee. Colombian coffee's high acidity and bright flavor can irritate those with a sensitive stomach.[4]

So, Which Colombian K Cup Should You Buy?

I loved tasting all the Colombian K cups on the list, and they all have unique qualities that make them stand out. However, Folgers Colombian K-cup is the one I recommend.

The medium roast coffee is smooth but satisfying, with the mix of chocolate and citrus notes that you want from a Colombian blend. Plus, it’s versatile and can be used for many coffee drinks.

Experienced coffee lovers may prefer something more complex, but almost all coffee drinkers will appreciate Folgers Colombian K-cups.

There are lots of great coffee options on the list and something for everyone. I recommend looking through all the K cups until you find the one that matches your preferences.

Our #1 Colombian Coffee K-Cup

Taste

5.0

Size Options

4.5

Value For Money

5.0


Overall Rating

4.8

References: 

1. https://www.mdpi.com/2306-5710/6/3/44
2. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/341260539_Roasting_Conditions_and_Coffee_Flavor_A_Multi-Study_Empirical_Investigation
3. https://revistia.org/files/articles/ejnm_v4_i1_21/Caracostea.pdf
4. https://www.healthline.com/nutrition/is-coffee-acidic#bottom-line 

Kayla Stavridis

Head of Marketing

Kayla Stavridis
Kayla Stavridis is a coffee enthusiast and Head of Marketing for Barista HQ. She blends her professional insights and experience with a deep passion for all things coffee. Kayla offers a unique, hands-on perspective on coffee culture and trends. You can find her sipping a cold brew with just a touch of milk on the beach in the afternoon and a Corona with lime in the evening.

My favorite drink? I'd go with... Cold Brew

See Our Editorial Processes

Meet Our Team

Share Feedback

Leave a Comment